106.11 智慧財產權月刊 VOL.227
15
本月專題
美國法院對於角色著作權保護之判斷標準―
研析美國第九巡迴上訴法院
DC Comics v. Towle
一案
͉ࣩ
৫ج
Ⴉሆሂԓίဘʕ
ڷ
˸̻ࠦྡᅵяତeཥൖᅂණʿཥᅂ
ʕ
ڷ
˸
3D
ͭӛԓᅼۨяତd
ڢ
ස
މ
Ⴇ˖ഹЪʕٙԉЍfΪϾdሆሂԓ
̮ٙᝈ
ה
яତ˸ሆሂ̮Җʿतࣿ̌ঐʘഐΥdٙᆽϞਗ਼௴จۜሯᜑତ
༈ԉЍʘྼ
༺ڌ
38
f
ୋɚdʔሞОࣛяତdԉЍ̂ʱᖭԑ˸ԴՉ፫Ⴉ̈
the
character must be sufficiently delineated to be recognizable as same character
whenever it appears
39
iϤᅺ
ڷ
͜ϽඎԉЍʔΝᗳۨٙഹЪʕ̈ତ
ࣛdՉԉЍतሯ̀яତɓ
ߧ
ʿ̙፫ᗆdኋ၍ԉЍԨʔɓ֛ၪܵ
Ν̮ٙᝈ
40
d݂Ϥ
ࠅ
Ч
ו
ᘱəԉЍу݂ԫᅺʘၚग़dԨ˲͟ԉЍ̮
ᝈึᎇഹ݂ԫઋືeఙ౻ϾϞ
ה
ʔΝd್νԉЍततሯяତɓ
ߧ
ʿ̙
፫ᗆd
ۆ
တԑୋɚ
ࠅࡈ
f
͉ࣩ
৫ج
ႩሆሂԓІ
1941
ϋဘ
೮ڋ
ఙࣛԙʦdɓٜၪܵዹतྼ
̮ᝈԨяତආ
ۃ
ሊ௴จٙतሯdৰϞԘˀᏐٙዚਗ̌ঐ̮dሆሂ
ԓৣ௪৷၌ༀໄʿ؛ኜd˸пሆሂ
ڪ
͂Ꮨ͕ໆfሆሂԓ˸νሆሂ
ٙॼၶdԓ
ۃ
ֻ
ܝ
ַФdԨৣϞ൴ɽԣᚐؐe
ݴ
ᇞۨኺࠬ
و
ʿሆ
ሂᏏdᒱ್ሆሂԓ̮ٙۨεϋԸяତʔɓᅵٙࠦႶdШΤ၈ሆሂԓe
͜ሆሂ
ࡈڪ
ɛਖ਼͜Ը͂Ꮨ͕ໆतᅄഃतᅄʥՈϞɓ
ߧ
dνሆሂ
ԓ
ڭ
ܵΈٙ
ݴ
ᇞ̮ۨdᜫሆሂ
ڪ
̙˸Ⴠછ˸࿁Ҥెᚡdίဘʕd
ሆሂԓᖭϓ̂တঐඎٙᒺ৵dяତᎇࣛඅ
؞ݴ
ًٙ࿒d
א
݊Չᄝ࢛ˏᏗᄝ࢛̈Շྠ˦ೋdփᔴЧήν٤ʕཱུᒹছઽઠdԘ
ዧडਗϓɓंૅ˸
ک
Փᅳࢯf
Ͼ
1966
ϋཥൖᅂණၾ
1989
ϋཥᅂ
و
͉ٙሆሂԓ͵Ϟৣ௪ᄝ࢛ˏᏗ
ʿ˦ೋᄝ࢛၍dԴሆሂԓኹϞၾɓছԓሿʔΝٙঐඎfϤ̮dሆሂԓІ
ҢሜືঐɢϞйɓছԓሿdν
1966
ϋཥൖᅂණٙ
و
͉dሆሂԓீ
ཀ˦ᇋˏᏗٙૅᔷൿːᚨਗɢdੂБ྅ሆሂছٙၡ
ܢ
ᔷ
emergency
bat turn
fΝᅵήd
1989
ϋཥᅂ
و
͉ٙሆሂԓ̙ᔷᜊ
މ
ሆሂ࠭ᅁᅼό
38
Id.
39
Rice v. Fox Broadcasting Co., 330 F. 3d 1170 (9th Cir. 2003).
40
Halicki Films, LLC v. Sanderson Sales & Mktg., 547 F.3d 1213, 1224 (9th Cir.2008).