8
106.12 智慧財產權月刊 VOL.228
本月專題
論專利可據以實現要件―以未充分揭露技術手段為探討核心
ٝνОᐏ՟ሗӋධʕሗӋ
ي
claimed product
i߰ᄲ
ݟ
ژ
̙ሞᗇ͡ሗࣩ͊̂
ʱ౧ᚣd
ۆ
Աᆄ
ݲ
ਖ਼л҅ᄲ
ݟ
ܸ
ی
Part F III 1
7
֛ٙd͡ሗ˙ᏐᑘᗇνОྼତ
ה
ሗ೯ٙᇍఖf
二、案例介紹
Ϟᗫᆄ
ݲ
ਖ਼л҅ɪൡ։ࡰึ
T0541/97
ࣩԷdӻ
ن
ਖ਼лʘ೯Τ၈
މ
Ո˥
ʱ༆ॷʘരۜᓩኜ
Filter for smoking article comprising a water disintegrative
paper
d༈ࣩԷʮක
މ
EP 0612482A1
d͡ሗ˚ʿᎴᛆ˚ʱй
މ
1994
ϋ
2
˜
15
˚e
1993
ϋ
2
˜
23
˚fᄲ
ݟ
ཀʕd༈ࣩԷʘ͡ሗɛ
1995
ϋ
10
˜
20
˚
ࡌ
͍ٙሗӋධ
1
ܼ̍ආБ˥ंʱ༆Ϊɿ֛
ج
Moisture disintegration index test
method
ʘҦஔतᅄd್ᆄ
ݲ
ᄲ
ݟ
೯ژ
ତೌ
ج
І༈ࣩ͡ሗࣛ
౧ה
ᚣlz࢙Դ༈೯
᙮ה
ҦஔჯਹՈஷ੬ٝᗆ٫֛ٝ˥ंʱ༆ΪɿٙҦஔ˓
ݬ
dϾ
1999
ϋ
4
˜
21
˚ࣨჶ͡ሗࣩf͡ሗɛʔୌᄲ֛ഐ
؈
Ͼ̈ɪൡdᆄ
ݲ
ਖ਼л҅ɪൡ։ࡰึ
Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office
ආБᄲ
ܝݟ
Ӕᙄၪܵࣨჶഐ
؈
f
ݟ
ӻ
ن
ਖ਼л͡ሗɛ
1995
ϋ
10
˜
20
˚
ࡌ
͍ʘሗӋධ
1
މ
j
ɓ၇ՈϞॷሯཀᓩҿࣘٙരۜཀᓩಏd༈ॷሯཀᓩҿࣘՈϞʔ൴ཀ
10
ٙ˥
ंʱ༆Ϊɿi༈Ϊɿ
ڷ
˥ंʱ༆Ϊɿ֛
ج
֛
8
f
ᛓᗇҏ
Oral proceedings
ʕd͡ሗɛ
1998
ϋ
11
˜
26
˚̈༈֛
ج
ʊɓႡॷʮ̡ʕۜ͜ሯ၍છd̥݊༈ʮ̡̙ঐ֠͊ʮჯਹ
Public
domain
ʮකᗫ༟ৃd˲༈֛
ج
݊
ܘ
ᔊఊٙ˙
ج
9
fᆄ
ݲ
ਖ਼л҅ɪൡ։ࡰึ
ܸ̈Ҧஔ˓
ݬ
݊щᔊఊԨ
ڢ
ࠠᓃdίӚϞᗇኽᗇ༈֛
ج
ʮකᎴᛆ˚ʘ
ۃ
ًٙ
ر
ɨdਿ͡ሗࣛ
౧ה
ᚣlz࢙Ӕᙄʔୌᆄ
ݲ
ਖ਼лʮ
ߒ
ୋ
83
ૢʘ֛f
̤ίࣩԷ
T1329/07
ʕd͡ሗɛਗ਼ᅵۜ፧࢛
ה
Җϓٙཥှࣛਹৃᛌ̋Ї৷
ᕏৃ
ܝ
d༶͜ʔ൴ཀ
50 KHz
ٙЭ᎖ᇍఖཥှ
ت
ٙҦஔ˓
ݬ
ආБʱɿਈf༈ࣩ
7
http://documents.epo.org/projects/babylon/eponet.nsf/0/0791474853510FFFC125805A004C9571/$Fi
le/guidelines_for_examination_part_f_en.pdf (last visited Oct.11, 2017).
8
https://register.epo.org/application?documentId=EHHVE1T0Z9JVE07&number=EP94301089&lng=e n&npl=false (last visited Oct.25, 2017).
9
https://www.epo.org/law-practice/case-law-appeals/pdf/t970541eu1.pdf(last visited Oct.25, 2017).