12
106.12 智慧財產權月刊 VOL.228
本月專題
論專利可據以實現要件―以未充分揭露技術手段為探討核心
Ϟ౧ͪ˸ࡳ
ࡈ
ༀໄྼତ̌ঐdԨ͊ୌΥνОྼତ
ה
ሗ˙
ج
ʘҁ౧ᚣdΪϤ༼
ˀ
ߕ
ਖ਼л
ج
112
a
ʘ֛
22
fԱ
ߕ
༈ࣩԷdуԴ݊᙮˙
ج
ٙҦஔ˓
ݬ
d
ʥცԴ༈೯
᙮ה
ҦஔჯਹՈஷ੬ٝᗆ٫ٝྼତ༈Ҧஔ˓
הݬ
ცༀໄdˈՉ݊
ה
ሗ˙
ڢج
ۃ
Ҧஔʘɓছ
ࠇ
ၑዚу̙ੂБࣛdһᏐҁ౧ᚣ݊л͜О၇ༀໄʿ
Չ˸ੂБ༈˙
ج
f
ߕ
ਖ਼лᄲ
ݟ
˓̅ୋ
2100
2164.06
a
I
23
ܸ̈dࣩԷ
501 F.3d 1274
Ԩ͊
͡ሗࣛ౧ᚣҖϓཥɿਉࠦᅜᏘਈኜٙື
א
ཥ༩dΪϾೌ
ج
Դ༈೯
᙮ה
Ҧ
ஔჯਹՈஷ੬ٝᗆ٫ٝႡЪeԴ͜
ה
ሗ೯ٙҦஔ˓
ݬ
dኬ
ߧ
ʔୌኽ˸ྼତ
ࠅ
֛f༈ࣩԷٙਖ਼лʮක
މ
US 5231253
d೯Τ၈
މ
ਉࠦᅜᏘਈኜ
Side Impact Sensors
d
ڷ
1992
ϋ
6
˜
2
˚̈͡ሗϾ
1993
ϋ
7
˜
27
˚ʮකf
༈ࣩԷٙሗӋධ
1
މ
j
Ո
ܝۃ
ቃʘԓሿʕਈਉᗙላᅜฦᕸٙਈኜdܼ̍ɓ̮ಠeՉʕᏐ
༈̮ಠʘ̋Ͼ࿁ਗٙሯ෯eί༈̮ಠ̋൴ཀཫணⳫ
࠽
ࣛΫᏐ
ࠑה
ሯ෯ਗϾ઼ਗ
ڭ
ᚐ
࠱
ࡰٙʈՈd˸ʿί༈ԓሿ
ۃ
e
ܝ
ቃʕːʘගϾЇˇ
ɓԓሿਉ
ژ
eɓԓሿਉٙЗໄ˙Σɪτༀ
ࠑה
̮ಠ˸ਈ༈ԓሿਉ
ה
աላᅜ
ٙʈՈ
24
f
ί༈ࣩԷႭࣣୋ
10
ᙷୋ
7
Ї
14
Бʕd͡ሗɛ౧ᚣə༈ਈኜ
ڷ
ཥɿਈኜd
Ш͊ʿ༈ਈኜʕཥɿʱҦஔ˓
ݬ
dΪϤ
ج
ࢬᄲଣಂගሯဲʔୌኽ˸ྼ
ତ
ࠅ
֛ٙfᒱ͡ሗɛ͡ూʊ̂ʱ౧ᚣ༈ਈኜٙዚʈՈdШ
ߕ
৫ج
ٙจ
Ԉ
މ
d͉ࣩ͡ሗࣛ
ה
ӚϞ౧ᚣਉࠦᅜᏘਈኜٙҦஔ˓
ݬ
ᇍఖķܼ̍ཥɿe
ዚՇʱٙᇍఖÑЇ̙ኽ˸ྼତdΪϤкӔ
ה
ሗ೯ʔୌ̙ኽ˸ྼତ
ࠅ
25
f
三、分析
ࣩ͟Է
442 F.2d 985
̙̈dуԴ݊᙮˙
ج
ٙҦஔ˓
ݬ
dʥცԴ༈೯
᙮ה
ҦஔჯਹՈஷ੬ٝᗆ٫ٝྼତ༈Ҧஔ˓
הݬ
ცༀໄdʑ̙ୌΥ
ߕ
̂ʱ౧ᚣe
22
https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F2/442/442.F2d.985.8458.html(last visited Oct.12,
2017).
23
Νൗ
19
f
24
https://www.google.com/patents/US5231253(last visited Oct.12, 2017).
25
https://casetext.com/case/automotive-tech-v-bmw-of-na(last visited Oct.12, 2017).