106.09 智慧財產權月刊 VOL.225
11
本月專題
進步性判斷方式及論理之探討―以發明專利進步性審查基準修訂為例
ஔᏐ͜௪ҷԄ
ready for improvement
ʘ୦ٝༀໄ˙
אج
ପ
ي
˲ପ̙͛ཫಂʘഐ
؈
26
i
E
ᜑ̙༊j͟ɓϞࠢᅰඎʘᆽႩʿ
̙ཫಂٙ༆Ӕ˙ࣩʕ፯dz༆Ӕ˙ࣩd˲Ϟϓ̌ٙΥଣಂ
ܙ
27
i
F
ਿண
ࠇ
ႰΪ
א
̹ఙცӋd
ڮ
ԴҷᜊΝ
א
ʔΝჯਹʕʘЧༀໄd˲
༈ҷᜊ
೯މ
᙮ה
ҦஔჯਹʕՈϞஷ੬ٝᗆ٫̙ཫಂ٫
28
i
G
ۃ
Ҧ
ஔʕٙͪe
ܔ
ᙄ
א
ਗዚ
TSM
Դஷ੬ٝᗆ٫
ࡌ
ུ
א
ଡ଼Υ୦ٝҦஔ
˸ҁϓ͡ሗਖ਼лʘ೯
29
f
(三)建立初步顯而易知
༰ቇٙᜑϾٝʱܼؓ̍ɧӉfdᄲ
ݟ
ɛࡰᏐ
ܔ
ͭ
Graham
ԫྼሜ
ݟ
ٙ
ڋ
ӉᜑϾٝ
prima facie obviousness
dܼ̍൙П
О˕ܵՈϞਖ਼лʘᗇኽܼ̍Ⴍࣣ
༱ה
ʿ͡ሗɛ
ה
̈fટഹdᑘ
ᗇபఱᔷՑ͡ሗɛԒɪd͟͡ሗɛ̈ˀᗇ
rebuttal evidence
ʿÿ
א
͡ూଣ͟Ըдd௰
ܝ
dᄲ
ݟ
ɛࡰ̀൙ПΌٙԫྼʿ
ה
Ϟٙᗇኽ̍
ܼᄲ
ݟ
ɛࡰ
ה
̈ʿ͡ሗɛ
ה
̈ԸӔ֛ࠠอϽඎ݊щʥ̙˕ܵ༈
೯࿁͡ሗࣛٙஷ੬ٝᗆ٫ϾԊ
މڷ
ᜑϾٝ
30
f
三、日本特許廳(
JPO
)
(一)審查進步性的步驟
JPO
ᄲ
ݟ
ආӉٙӉ
މ
j
A
ᆽ֛͡ሗਖ਼лʘ೯d
B
ᆽႩɓ
א
ልᅰ
ࡈ
ˏ͜೯dʕ፯ɓ˴
ࠅ
ˏᗇd
C
ˢ࿁͡ሗਖ਼лʘ೯
26
Ϥሞଣ̀݊
1
ۃ
Ҧஔ̍ўdzਿ͉ༀໄ˙
אج
ପ
ي
dϾ͡ሗਖ਼лʘ೯̙ൖ
މ
ਿ༈
ਿ͉ༀໄʘdzҷԄༀໄi
2
ۃ
Ҧஔ̍ўdz୦ٝҦஔdՉ̙Ꮠ͜༈ਿ͉ༀໄ˙
אج
ପ
ي
i
3
༈ஷ੬ٝᗆ٫ʊႩٝᏐ͜༈୦ٝҦஔਗ਼ପ̙͛ཫಂʘഐ
؈
˲̙ᐏ
ߧ
dzҷԄʘӻ୕f
27
Ϥሞଣ̀݊
1
೯ࣛᓃd༈ҦஔჯਹʊϞႩٝٙਪᕚ
א
ცӋdՉʕ̙ঐܼ̍ண
ࠇ
ც
Ӌ
א
̹ఙᏀɢɨც
༆ࠅ
Ӕʘਪᕚi
2
০࿁
ה
Ⴉٝٙਪᕚ
א
ცӋdʊϞϞࠢᅰඎʘʊᆽႩ˲
̙ཫಂٙ༆Ӕ˙ࣩi
3
༈ஷ੬ٝᗆ٫л͜༈ഃ༆Ӕ˙ࣩՈϞΥଣ̙ཫಂٙϓ̌f
28
Ϥሞଣ̀݊
1
ೌሞ݊щၾ͡ሗਖ਼лʘ೯᙮Ν
א
ʔΝٙӺჯਹd
ۃ
Ҧஔʘᇍఖʿ
lz࢙̍ў
אڐ
ᗳЧٙༀໄ˙
אج
ପ
ي
i
2
ՈϞண
ࠇ
ႰΪ
א
̹ఙცӋˏ೯ҷᜊ༈୦ٝༀ
ໄ˙
אج
ପ
ي
i
3
ሗӋʘ೯ၾ
ۃ
Ҧஔٙࢨମ᙮
ۃ
Ҧஔ୦ٝٙᜊʷ
୦א
ٝٙࡡ
ۆ
i
4
༈ஷ੬ٝᗆ٫ਿண
ࠇ
ႰΪ
א
̹ఙცӋ̙Ꮠ͜༈
ۃ
Ҧஔ
ה
˴ੵٙ୦ٝᜊʷd˲༈୦ٝᜊ
ʷ
༈މ
ஷ੬ٝᗆ٫̙ཫಂ٫f
29
Ϥሞଣ̀݊
1
ۃ
Ҧஔ˖ᘠʕ
༈א
ஷ੬ٝᗆʕϞͪe
ܔ
ᙄ
א
ਗዚԸ
ࡌ
ུ
ۃ
Ҧஔ
א
ଡ଼
Υ
ۃ
Ҧஔi
2
ՈϞΥଣ̙ཫಂٙϓ̌f
30
USPTO, MPEP 2142 (at 2100-141,142), 2144.08 (at 2100-180,181) (Rev. 07, 2015. 11).