10 /120
10
本月專題
美國專利舉發制度及其相關爭議問題簡介――以多方複審（
IPR
）案件為中心
105.09 智慧財產權月刊 VOL.213
ʘ
ن
ᓃd˲Չࣖɢʿ
ܝ
ᚃί
USPTO
eή˙
א৫ج
ITC
ʘࣩfϾОፗίᄲଣ
ҏʕΥଣ̙̈ʘ
ن
ᓃdধᑘ
Dell Inc. v. Electronics and Telecommunications
Research Institute
ETRI
ࣩЪ
މ
Ⴍf
Dell
࿁
ETRI
ʘୋ
6,978,346
ਖ਼лӻ
ن
ਖ਼л
ܝ
̈
2
IPR
ࣩࣩj
IPR2013-00635
e
IPR2015-00549
dί
IPR2013-00635
ࣩʕd
Dell
˴ੵӻ
ن
ਖ਼л
ሗӋධ
1
Ї
9
ʔՈอ²
102
b
א
ʔՈආӉ²
103
a
ن
ᓃ༉
ν
ڌ
2
f
PTAB
ᄲଣdසఱ
ن
ᓃǽʱʚ˸ࣩͭdԨЪ̈ᑘ೯ʔϓͭʘ௰
Ӕ֛f
࿁
Dell
ෛ
הܝ
ʘ
IPR2015-00549
ࣩd
PTAB
Ⴉ
މ
Չၾ
ۃ
IPR
ࣩѩ
މ
Ν
ᑘ೯ɛd˲
ۃ
IPR
ࣩʊᐏ௰Ӕ֛d
ڋ
Ӊʊတԑ
ߕ
ਖ਼л
ج
ୋ
315
e
1
ૢ
֛ʘ
ࠅ
fЇΥଣ̙̈٫d͟
AIA
ج
ࣩʘͭ
ج
ዝᝈʘdᏐᄿ
ع
ή
༆ᙑ
މ
̍ўɓᆞᇖʘᏨ॰ɛࡰා
ۈ
Ꮸ॰
ܝ
̙Υଣήཫಂึ೯ତʘ
ۃ
Ҧஔίlz
18
f
ఱ
ܝ
IPR
ࣩϾԊd
2
ᗇኽᗇኽ
2
e
5
19
ѩ
މ
ί
ۃ
IPR
ࣩʕʊ̈٫dᜑ
್
Dell
ϘʊٝϞϤ
2
ᗇኽd˲ᗇኽ
2
ۃ
IPR
ࣩʕಀЪ
މ
ӻ
ن
ਖ਼лʔՈආ
Ӊʘ˴ੵdΪϤ˸ᗇኽ
2
e
5
ʘଡ଼Υ˴ੵӻ
ن
ਖ਼лʔՈආӉdɗ
މ
Dell
ί
ۃ
IPR
ࣩʕ̙̈ʘ
ن
ᓃdᏐϞɓԫʔΎଣʘቇ͜dϾʔ
ܝ
IPR
ࣩʕ̈f
18
Dell Inc. v. ETRI
, IPR2015-00549 , paper 10 (PTAB decision - denial of institution of Inter
Partes Review and denial of motion for joinder), p. 4-5 (March 26, 2015).
19
Dell
ה
ᗇኽ
2
މ
Mylex
ʮ̡ʘࣣͣͤdᗇኽ
5
މ
US pat. 5,574,950
f
表
2
Dell
於
2
件
IPR
案中所提之爭點列表
IPR2013-00635
IPR2015-00549
ن
ᓃ ሗӋධ
ج
ૢ ᗇኽ ሗӋධ
ج
ૢ ᗇኽ
Ǻ
1-3
e
8
²
103
a
1+2
1-9
²
103
a
2+5
ǻ
4
e
9
²
103
a
1+2+3
Ǽ
5-7
²
103
a
1+2+4
ǽ
1-3
e
5-8
²
102
b
5